random Afghanistan links

Jean-Dominique Merchet writes about the Soviet withdrawal from Afghanistan, and argues that the political preparation and the overall strategy of it give cause for optimism. I’ve thought this before, and then doubted it.

There seems to be something of an optimism outbreak on after the London conference last week; here’s McChrystal, saying he expects that by December, a significant chunk of the Taliban will have gone quiet – notably, he seems to expect a lot of semi-supporters to jack it in quietly. Well, two Friedman units, eh. A significant tribe has apparently agreed to sign up with the Afghan government.

Ahmed Rashid has a must-read on talks during 2009. He argues that the major diplomatic story in this is that the Saudi and Afghan intelligence services have developed their own contacts to the Taliban, bypassing the Pakistani ISI.

al Sahwa discusses the Taliban shadow administration, which has some presence at least in 33 provinces of 34 and is a key element in any guerrilla army. NATO has picked a head of its civilian activities in Afghanistan.

Obviously, if part of the strategy is to bypass the ISI as interlocutors, then it’s going to be indispensable to compensate Pakistan on the other side of the table. As said here:

It would be a really fruitful thing for the Obama administration to start involving itself in an India-Pakistan peace process

However, this doesn’t seem to be happening. You’d think the point that there are limits to what Pakistan can do without pushing public tolerance too far, and that they need time to consolidate after last year’s fighting, would be obvious in the context of a “surge” based on counter-insurgency principles.

The Economist has a rather good story from Waziristan.

  1. dsquared

    I think that what McChrystal’s forecasting is what might be termed “an Iraqi success” – ie, failure, leaving the country in a state that was deemed horribly unacceptable a few years ago but which looks kind of OK compared to the intervening peak, then getting the hell out and hoping.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: